Letter from John Pullinger to Sir Bob Kerslake

UK Statistics Authority
1 Drummond Gate
Tel: (+44) 0207 592 8663
E-mail: [email protected]
John Pullinger CB CStat | National Statistician
Sir Bob Kerslake
Permanent Secretary
Department for Communities and Local Government
2 Marsham Street
30 January 2015
Dear Bob
I am writing regarding the Consultation on the future shape of the English Housing Survey, which the
Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) launched on 21 January 2015.
The consultation seeks views on how DCLG might improve the survey; and, specifically, on proposals
to pause the survey for one year in 2015/16, and/or run the survey on a biennial basis. It also seeks
advice on the value the survey currently provides to users.
The attached annex sets out some specific and significant uses of this survey, as well as the
implications of any pause or transition to a biennial survey. I also wanted to take this opportunity to set
out my overarching thoughts on this matter.
The English Housing Survey (EHS) and its predecessor surveys have formed key parts of a core
evidence base for housing and other policies since the 1980s. Uniquely, the Survey links information
collected from households with information on the fabric and condition of their home, which no other
survey does. It is the only data source where residents’ characteristics can be brought together with
data such as housing tenure, a household’s housing aspirations, and the condition of the housing
The EHS is used extensively across government and beyond and is a public good of national
I recognise, of course, the constraints that exist on public sector finances, but at a time of heightened
interest and rapid change in the housing market, I would urge the Department to consider most
carefully the implications any pause to the Survey would have for the long-term evidence base for
housing in England. If there is anything I can do to help explore possible options, please do not
hesitate to ask your officials to contact me.
I am copying this letter to the team responsible for the consultation.
Yours sincerely,
John Pullinger
Annex A
Uses of the survey
The English Housing Survey (EHS) is used extensively across government and beyond.
It has played a critical role in developing and delivering a range of housing policies including, for
example, the Right to Buy, regulation of the private rented sector, fire prevention initiatives, and the
reform of social housing allocation policies.
Data from the EHS currently provides the only source of information about the risks to health from
housing across England. It is also a key source for analysing the extent of over-crowding and underoccupation, and policies designed to address such issues.
The Survey is currently used to produce annual estimates of fuel poverty in England, and will remain
the prime source of information to monitor progress against the new target. Results are also used
where information is needed on physical characteristics of household properties, and it is the main
evidence on which discussions around the Winter Fuel Payment are based.
Current uses also include the compilation of UK measures of inflation. The Survey is used in the
derivation of annual dwelling stock weights used in the compilation of the Index of Private Housing
Rental Prices (IPHRP) and the owner occupied housing (OOH) component of CPIH. In addition data
are used to weight the Private Rented Property component that forms part of the CPI, CPIH, RPI, RPIJ
(and other variants of the indices). In addition, the EHS is used in modelling the broad age of properties
in the Census.
More widely, the EHS has an extensive range of external users, including local authorities, academics,
charities, commercial companies, and the general public. Typical local authority uses include utilising
EHS data to produce their housing allocations, tenancy policies or housing needs assessments.
Implications of pausing the English Housing Survey for one year in 2015-16 and/or running the
survey on a biennial basis are possible approaches to deliver cost savings.
A pause or shift to a biennial survey would undermine the production of up-to-date information on both
housing circumstances and the condition of stock.
Similarly, a pause or shift to a biennial survey might mean that it would no longer be possible to
produce a number of key statistics, including time series on the profile of housing stock, up-to-date
estimates of the extent of over-crowding and under-occupation, conformity with dwelling safety
standards, the extent of fuel poverty, and energy efficiency standards.
This is because data are currently combined across consecutive survey years in order to produce
sufficient sample sizes (a consequence of previous cost-saving measures). Unless sample sizes are
increased, with consequent additional costs, a biennial survey would substantially reduce the accuracy
and timeliness of results, consequently reducing the Survey’s value to decision makers.
The complex nature of data collection under the EHS means that reporting on fuel poverty is currently
lagged by approximately 18 months. A decision not to run the Survey in 2015/16 will mean that in
2018, the best information available on fuel poverty will by then be three years out of date.
The UK Statistics Authority will provide a more detailed technical note on the implications of the
proposals set out in the consultation before the end of the consultation period.