Joe Frey research Insight presentation

Research: Adding value in an
age of austerity
Joe Frey
Head of Research
Northern Ireland Housing Executive
The Research Unit
A client-led programme of research which
collects data to underpin analysis of:
Housing market
trends and
impact of policies
Customer views
of our services
Housing and
Impact of new
The role of research
• Late 1990s: evidence-informed policy and practice (EIPP) – “What
matters is what works”
• Quantitative (modelling future trends) and Qualitative (“through their
• The Journey to Excellence: more focused engagement with clients and
making an impact – outcomes more important
• Period of profound transformation against a background of austerity:
engaging with the sector and market intelligence
• Analyse and critique what is happening: more informed choices that
shape the future
• Painting a rounded picture for policy makers: cannot decide priorities
or fairness
Housing Market:
Review & Perspectives
• Key strategic document
• Synthesis of recent
housing research and
market intelligence
• Strategic context:
economic and sociodemographic drivers
• Developments in each of
the three main tenures
• Prospects for the coming
three-year period
House Price Index
• University of Ulster’s
mix-adjusted analysis:
open market
transactions from a
network of estate
• House price predictions
and reality!
Private Rented Sector
• Series of research projects
with UU:
• Analysis of changing nature of
• Attitudes of tenants: surprisingly
high levels of satisfaction with
landlord generally
• Profile of landlords and their
investment intentions
• DSD’s strategy for the PRS (2010)
• Tenancy Deposit Scheme
Housing Market Analysis
• Local Housing Systems Analysis: How they
operate and change over time
• Emphasises how different parts of the
system interact, what happens as a result
and how broader economic and sociodemographic trends affect the operation of
the system
• Not defined solely by local authority
administrative boundaries but by consumer
behaviour through house purchases/
• Understanding flows and processes vital to
effectively intervene to address system
imbalances or local problems
Housing Market Analysis
• More dynamic “systems
thinking” approach to
housing needs
assessment which
traditionally focused on
need for social housing.
• Underpins analysis of 11
Housing Market Areas in • Will continue to provide
evidence base in the
NI, as well as sub-market
future as the approach to
planning for housing
• Provides evidence base
mutates to meet the needs
of community planning.
for District Housing Plans.
House Condition Surveys
• NIHE has a statutory duty to undertake research
into housing conditions
• Data and analysis underpin an enormous range
of policies and decisions on distribution of
scarce resources
• Focus on two: where the impact and potential
impact in policy terms are significant
Reducing fuel poverty
• Investing in social housing to reduce fuel poverty
• Secondary analysis of House Condition Surveys
undertaken in 2009 and 2011. Modelling work
undertaken in partnership with the Building Research
Establishment (BRE)
• Research context:
• Household incomes generally drifting up (but disposable
income reducing in real terms); rising unemployment
• Energy prices rising steeply: by 65% from 2006-2011 (61%
• High dependency on oil (75%) and even solid fuel/ electricity
Rising oil prices in NI
Reducing fuel poverty in social housing
• Little can be done about the
price of fuel or incomes
• Strategy addresses fuel
source and insulation
• Total social housing stock:
• 2009-2011:
• 10,000 heating conversions
(solid fuel/electric to
• 3,000 new properties: Code
3 standard
• 25,000 properties
insulated/double glazing
Impact of Investment (1)
Fuel poverty in 2009:
• 44% (51% in social housing)
Fuel poverty in 2011:
• 42% (40% in social housing)
• In the private sector, fuel poverty rose
Cost of poor housing
• BRE modelled HCS data to
estimate the cost of poor
housing to the health
• ‘Poor housing’ defined as
having one or more
HHSRS Category 1 hazards
(e.g. excessive damp or
cold, food safety or
sanitation, falls on stairs):
20% of 2009 stock
Cost of poor housing (2)
• Using a model originally
developed by the
University of Warwick
• Based on estimating the
potential effects of
hazards on occupants and
visitors – in terms of
degree of seriousness and
• Estimated cost of
reducing Category 1
hazards to acceptable
level: £470m
• Estimated annual savings
to Health Service of £33m
per annum
• Payback period of 13
• Only includes 40% of cost
to society as a whole
Impact of Investment (2)
• Investment in social housing – and indeed all housing
– can make very significant differences to the health
and well-being of particular households
• There can be direct savings to the public purse…
• …As well as more indirect ones through higher
education standards and greater social inclusion
• If investment in social housing had not taken place –
more than 50% in fuel poverty!
Torrens: Solar Panel Water Heating
• Newly constructed by Fold:
112 houses built to Lifetime
Homes and EcoHomes
Excellent Standard
• Survey highlighted low
levels of employment (31%)
and high levels of benefit
• Survey highlighted generally
high levels of satisfaction –
but also lack of knowledge
and maintenance issues
Torrens: Solar Panel Water Heating
• Good Practice Guide for
social landlords
• Policies and procedures
relating to installation
and maintenance
• Advice on handover,
education, revisiting,
and tenancy
termination interviews
Research Programme 2015/16 (1)
Private sector housing
market analysis
Policy-related research
• House price indices
• Rental index
• Affordability measures
Housing Needs
Energy-related research
• House condition survey
• Household projections
• Housing need
Private rented sector
Tenancy deposit scheme
Health and housing
Supporting People
Assistive technology
• Fuel poverty
• Affordable Warmth
• Home improvement grants
Research Programme 2015/16 (2)
• Neighbourhood renewal surveys
• Building successful communities
Shared Communities
• Mapping segregation
• Shared communities surveys
Customer research
• Continuous Tenant Omnibus Survey
• Social Housing Reform Programme