Arizona Geological Society Newsletter

Arizona Geological Society
February 3, 2015 DINNER MEETING
Who: Don Yurewicz will present “Assessing Unconventional (Continuous) Hydrocarbon Resource Plays”
Where: Sheraton Tucson Hotel and Suites, 5151 East Grant Road, (at the intersection of Grant and
Rosemont on the North side of Grant in the PIMA BALLROOM (enter at northwest corner of the building)
and go upstairs to the meeting room.
When: Cash Bar at 6 p.m.—Dinner at 7 p.m.—Talk at 8 p.m.
Members $27, Guests $30, Students Members free with on-line reservation ($10 without).
RESERVATIONS ARE REQUIRED: CALL (520) 663-5295 or reserve on the AGS website
( by 11 a.m. Friday, January 30th. Please indicate Regular (Pork Loin
Medallions), Vegetarian, or Cobb Salad meal preference. Please cancel by 11 a.m. Friday, January 30th if you
are unable to attend - no shows and late cancellations will be invoiced.
The February dinner meeting is sponsored by:
Arizona Oil and Gas, Inc.
The Arizona Geological Society is grateful for Arizona Oil and Gas,
Inc.’s sponsorship, which helps us to offset dinner meeting costs.
Learn more about Arizona Oil and Gas at
Assessing Unconventional (Continuous) Hydrocarbon Resource Plays
Don Yurewicz, ExxonMobil (Retired)
Unconventional resources plays (also referred to as continuous resource plays) are regionally extensive hydrocarbon accumulations that lack any obvious relationship to structural closures or stratigraphic traps with
downdip water contacts. Reservoir and fluid properties vary considerably within these plays but most are
characterized by extremely small pores and very low permeability. Reservoirs include mudstones (shale),
sandstones, coals, and carbonates, and fluids range from dry gas to oil (including heavy oil). The established
processes for assessing conventional plays which relies on risking, sizing, and counting discrete prospects or
fields is not applicable for continuous plays (Hood and Yurewicz, 2008). Most continuous resource plays are
Continued on Page 2
ABSTRACT - Continued from Page 1
better assessed as a single large hydrocarbon accumulation with highly variable resource density. Because
economic margins may be thin in these plays, business success often depends on early identification of favorable areas with higher resource density, which in turn correlates to areas of better well performance. In addition to determining in-place and recoverable volumes, the assessment methodology for continuous resources
must, therefore, be flexible enough to map variable resource density, to relate hydrocarbon volumes to well
performance, and to adapt to situations ranging from little or no well data to thousands of wells (Hood,
Yurewicz and Steffen, 2012).
Play assessment provides a powerful mechanism for integrating geologic insights into business decisions. To
incorporate the unique aspects of continuous resources, a process was developed to apply a hybrid grid and
polygon based methodology (Hood and Yurewicz, 2008). The play is subdivided into a series of analysis polygons that provide the basis for probabilistic calculations. The polygon boundaries can be dynamic (mapped
geologic limits), static (leases), arbitrary, or some combination of these. Those geologic properties mapped
spatially as grids (e.g. gross thickness, net-to-gross, or porosity) are evaluated within each analysis polygon to
obtain inputs for the probabilistic assessment. Geologic properties that are not available as spatially varying
estimates can be assigned directly with appropriate ranges of uncertainty. Resource uncertainty can be captured both as ranges around most likely parameter estimates and as multiple geologic or operational scenarios.
Risk dependency and volumetric correlation must be defined in order to obtain robust probabilistic aggregations of multiple analysis polygons. Fully probabilistic results lead to better informed business decisions by
providing information on high-side and low-side outcomes.
Ultimately, assessments based on well performance provide the clearest indication of the recoverable resource
and economic viability of a play. Unfortunately, well performance-based approaches are not reliable until a
high operational efficiency has been achieved and the number of wells with adequate production histories is
sufficient to clarify the primary controls on resource density. To provide early prediction of well performance
within the context of volumetric assessment, probabilistic ranges of well EURs are estimated for each assessment polygon based on volumetric inputs coupled with assumptions about likely drainage areas (Hood,
Yurewicz and Steffen, 2012). As performance-based EUR projections become available for wells, they can
be compared to the specific recoverable volume prediction from the resource density grid along with the distribution of well EURs predicted for the polygon.
Well performance is key to the economic viability of a play. Combining analog datasets of initial potential
(IP) with well EUR provides a dynamic linkage of the volumetric assessment to well performance. Applying
relationships between EUR and IP from analog plays to EUR curves (one per polygon) for the play of interest
yields spatially varying families (distributions) of IP’s. By recasting assessed volumes in terms of well productivity, this process supports economic analyses explicitly linked to spatially varying geologic inputs.
Hood, K. C., and D. A. Yurewicz, 2008, Assessing the Mesaverde basin-center gas play, Piceance Basin,
Colorado: AAPG Hedberg Series No. 3, p. 87-104.
Hood, K. C., D. A. Yurewicz, and K. J. Steffen, 2012, Assessing continuous resources – building the bridge
between static and dynamic analyses: Bul. Canadian Petroleum Geology, v. 60, p. 1-22.
About the February Dinner Speaker
Don Yurewicz received a B.A. in geology from Rutgers University (1970)
in New Jersey and M.S. (1973) and Ph.D. (1976) degrees in geology from
the University of Wisconsin. Don’s graduate work at Wisconsin focused
on sedimentology, stratigraphy and diagenesis of deep- to shallow-marine
Don began his career as a research specialist in carbonates at Exxon Production Research Company in Houston in 1977. His research focused on
the hydrocarbon source potential of carbonate rocks and the application of
fluorescence microscopy in carbonate petrographic studies. He also assisted in exploration and production projects of carbonate reservoirs at
Prudhoe Bay in Alaska, the Maracaibo Basin in Venezuela, the Midland
Basin in West Texas, and in the South China Sea. Teaching was a major part of his work at Exxon’s research
center and he led courses in modern and ancient carbonates for Exxon offices around the world.
He then transferred to an exploration assignment in 1985. His work ranged from prospect and play identification in the U. S. Gulf Coast and Mid-continent regions, to an array of regional studies in North and South
America, the Middle East, and the Caspian focusing on hydrocarbon systems, reservoir characterization, basin
modelling and hydrocarbon assessment.
Don began working on unconventional resources in 2002 when he conducted a study of fluid distribution in
tight gas sandstones in the Piceance Basin, Colorado. While working in the Piceance Basin he helped assessors from the Technology division of ExxonMobil in the development of a methodology for assessing this unconventional play. That methodology was later adapted for evaluating a broad range of unconventional plays
including shale gas, tight oil, coal bed methane, and heavy oil. During the last 7 years of his career, Don specialized in assessing unconventional resources and assisted in evaluation of unconventional plays around the
world. Teaching remained an integral part of Don’s long career. In addition to teaching in carbonate schools,
Don developed a popular field seminar in unconventional resources and a workshop for assessing unconventional resources.
Arizona Geological Society Membership Stats
Total Membership
Professional Members
Student Members
Organizational Members
A Special Note of Thanks!
Ralph Stegen served as AGS Ex. Com. Vice President for Field Trips for 2014 before resigning in January
2015. As field trip VP, Ralph organized two highly successful trips: the first to Freeport-McMoRan’s Christmas Mine property (approximately 40-50 AGS members attended); and a trip to Sabino Canyon to examine
debris flow deposits (with ~ 25 AGS member attending).
Ralph, on behalf of AGS membership and the AGS Ex. Com, thank you for your service.
In Memoriam
Dr, Harold “Hal” Bohmer
(Published in Arizona Daily Star (January 4, 2015)
Harold "Hal" Bohmer died Monday, December 29, 2014, at home
in Tucson, Arizona, surrounded by his loving family after a short
Hal was born in Northampton, Massachusetts, in 1930 and attended Williston Academy, now known as the WillistonNorthampton School. He graduated from Amherst College following four years of service in the U.S. Navy during the Korean
War. Hal went on to complete both an M.S. degree and a Ph.D. in
geology at the University of Cincinnati, where he was awarded
two National Science Foundation Fellowships.
He then worked as senior research scientist for P.P.G. Industries for 34 years. He worked in the research facility in Barbarton, Ohio, and then for the last six years of his career in Monroeville, PA. Research expeditions in
Sierra Leone and Greenland were highlights of his career.
He retired to Tucson with Cynthia in 2002. As avid hikers, they enjoyed many adventures with their children
and grandchildren, as well as numerous off-road geological expeditions with family and friends in his Jeep
Wrangler. He was an active member of the Arizona Geological Society. He loved Tucson, the Santa Catalina
Mountains, and the wildlife.
Offered For Sale ($10,000)
Olympus Innov-X Alpha 6000 X-Ray
Spectrometer, with case, stationary
stand, and 3 batteries. S/N 9708.
Manufactured March, 2008. The XRay gun has had 220 hours of use.
We paid over $30,000 for it new in
2008. Money back guarantee.
Contact Rex Loesby
E-mail - [email protected]
Tel/Cell: 303-771-9610
Shining a Light on the Lindgren Collection
In January 2002, the University of Arizona’s Dept. of Geosciences (UA) acquired the Waldemar Lindgren Ore
Collection from Harvard University. AGS and the Tucson Gem and Mineral Society played a pivotal role by
jointly providing ~$25,000 for curating and transport of the collection to Tucson.
For 12 years the collection has been secure in a shed off campus in Tucson. The Lindgren Ore Collection – at
a glance:
10 shrink-wrapped wood pallets (see picture)
~ 840 boxes of minerals and rocks
~ 10,000 hand specimens in individual trays
Assorted paperwork and perfunctory catalog listing the 840 boxes, generally by location.
Many samples have much more specific locality and specimen descriptions written on labels in the
bottom of individual trays.
AGS Ex. Com. member Bruce Walker shepherding 10 pallets of boxes of rocks and minerals that
comprise the Lindgren Ore Collection.
A representative example of sample information from
the collection. Before arriving at Harvard the collection
was curated by the Economic Geology program at MIT.
What to do? The Lindgren Collection has been gathering dust for the past 12 years. It appears the time is right
to revisit with our UA and TGMS colleagues, how we can leverage the collection to benefit science and the
general public.
The AGS Executive Committee will hear a proposal at February’s Executive Committee meeting to form a
sub-committee to explore what options exist for the Lindgren Collection. That sub-committee should comprise representatives from UA Geosciences, AGS Executive Committee, TGMS and other interested parties.
We’ll keep you informed going forward. In the meantime, if you have ideas or thoughts for curating or displaying the collection, please reach out to one of our AGS Executive Committee members with the details.
Due to high costs, the Arizona Geological Society’s phone message service will be discontinued on January
31, 2015. After that time, those making dinner reservations or wishing to contact us must do so on-line.
AGS Spring-2015 Field Trip – Save the Date (2-3 May 2015)
(Photo taken from Presentation for AHS Symposium, September 19, 2012)
Geologist and long-time AGS member Paul Lindberg has graciously offered to guide AGS to the Mormon
Mountain area south of Flagstaff to examine Basin and Range structures encroaching on the Colorado Plateau.
Paul recently led an AIPG group through the same area.
For a detailed description of the geology of Oak Creek and the nearby Mormon Mountain Graben see Paul
Lindberg’s 31-page paper in the Oak Creek Watershed book now available at the AZGS’s Arizona Experience.
Date – Field trip sets off from Flagstaff at 7:30 a.m. on Saturday 2 May.
All day excursion to Mormon Mountain and environs.
Level of difficulty – low; there is one short rock scramble along Oak Creek.
We are looking at options for at a half-day trip to the San Francisco volcanic field for the following day.
Logistics – To be announced.
2015 Doug Shakel Memorial Student Poster Event
Arizona Geological Society’s annual Doug Shakel Memorial Student Poster Event will been held at the Arizona State University science center on Saturday, April 18, 2015. There will be a morning poster event, including display, oral presentations and the award of prizes. This will be followed by a catered lunch and a
tour of the ASU’s new Science Center. More details about this event will be announced in next month’s
There will be no regular monthly AGS meeting in April.
Arizona Geological Survey News Brief
Arizona Mining Review (AMR) e-Video Magazine – 1/27/2015
AMR salutes the annual Tucson Gem and Mineral Show display scheduled for 12-15 Feb. at the Tucson Convention Center. Peter Megaw, TGMS Show Exhibit Chair, joins Lee to describe the magnificent minerals of
Western Europe that will be on display. AMR will be broadcast at 10:00 am MST on 27 January on
LiveStream and will be immediately available at our AZGS YouTube Channel .
Guest & Topics
Nyal Niemuth (AZGS) on the impact of declining copper prices on the AZ mining community.
Peter Megaw – TGM Show
New Publications – Online at the AZGS Document Repository
Conway, F.M. and Davis, R. (eds.), 2014, Annual Report of the Arizona Geological Survey: Fiscal Year 2014.
Arizona Geological Survey Open-File Report OFR-14-07, 52 p.
Keith, S.B., 1983, Results of mapping project near Ray Pinal County, Arizona. Arizona Geological Survey
Open-File Report OFR-83-14, 74 p., 11 map plates, map scale 1:12,000. (Now available online.)
Singleton, J, Bird, E. and Hatfield, M. 2014, Geologic map of the southern Lincoln Ranch basin, Buckskin
Mountains, west-central Arizona. Arizona Geological Survey Contributed Map CM-14-B, Map scale
Slated for release on the week of Jan. 26, 2015. New or revised earth fissure mapping:
DM-EF-1 v. 2, Chandler Heights Study area
DM-8-EF, v. 2, Luke Study Area
DM-EF-27, v. 1, Avra Valley
DM-EF-28, v. 1, McMullen Valley
Welcome New AGS Members
Robert Balcells
Larry Krause
Amanda Welch
Mark Emerson
Kelly Proctor
Jody Williams
The AGS Thanks Our 2014 Sponsors for their Support
Please mail check with membership form to: Arizona Geological Society, PO Box 40952, Tucson, AZ 85717
Dues (check box)  1 year: $20;  2 years, $35;  3 years: $50;  full-time student (membership is free)
NEW MEMBER or RENEWAL? (circle one)
Date of submittal
Mailing Address:
Work Phone:
Home Phone:
Fax Number:
Cellular Phone:
Zip Code:
Check this box if you do not have an email address 
All newsletters will be sent by email. If you do not have an email address, we will mail a hard copy to you, but we
cannot guarantee timeliness.
If registered geologist/engineer, indicate registration number and State:
Enclosed is a
tax-deductible contribution to the J. Harold Courtright  or AGS Scholarship  Funds.