The Community Orchardist - is a Holistic

The Community Orchardist
January 2015
Michael Phillips, Editor
I was up this past night stalking spirits. So it seemed. Out in the dark,
chasing deer from my apple trees. Three of them run a short ways into the
woods to stare back at me, less than a hundred feet from where I stand,
spotlight in hand. I’m now carrying a big gun (along with a hard-earned
depredation permit) and through the scope her chest looks like the side of a
barn … but I lower the gun, and whisper ‘one last chance, you.’ Sadly, we will
meet again as this family trio has learned to leap between hot wires of the
hi-tensile fence without being shocked. Our crop has been severely thinned
across the lower scaffolds as a result. Still, a hearty optimism beats in my
chest as the days start to lengthen. Biological insights from this past season
are downright exciting. That’s what you will be reading about in this issue of
CO. Meanwhile, out there, this coming summer, good fungi and feeder roots
and braconids and competing bacteria will somehow abet miracles.
All this will go unseen … like me and those deer in the light of the night.
Holistic Overview
Winter conference season is here, and that means a guy needs to find his stride
again as teacher. A quick overview of holistic management sets the stage:
Ecosystem Health is achieved through stewarding biological connections,
investing in mineral balance, and encouraging outrageous habitat diversity.
Crop Production keys to a healthy tolerance for disease. Plant metabolism
points the way to enhanced immune function and competitive colonization as
the means to keeping pathogens at bay. What results are apples and other
wonderful fruits that indeed keep the doctor away.
A spot of science launches us down the green immunity highway. Keep in mind
that this is totally different thinking from conventional agriculture, be it chemical or
old school organic. We will come to the other side with an appreciation for plant
defense mechanisms that frankly have kept this planet humming for ages.
Systemic Acquired Resistance & Induced Systemic Resistance
Fruit trees resist disease through engaged phytochemistry. Growers working
with plant immune function produce nutrient dense fruit with more medicinal
oomph as a result. Our fruit always tastes over the top. Systemic acquired
resistance (SAR) and induced systemic resistance (ISR) are the underlying
scientific principles behind holistic recommendations for nutrient sprays packed
with biological reinforcement.
Some outright blasphemy right off should certainly get thinking caps in gear:
A tad of disease presence is good.
Some pest activity needs to be appreciated.
Plants react to a broad range of insects and microbial pathogens having different
lifestyles and infection strategies. Each intruder commences a series of
phytochemical responses by the plant in turn. One fascinating part of this story
involves warning neighboring trees and associated plant friends (communicating
via the mycelial network) that so-and-so is back in town.
Community Orchardist: JAN 2015
The specific defenses being activated consist of an array of small-molecule
hormones. (Not unlike our own innate immune system using enzyme signaling to
bring on the phagocytes!.) These signaling pathways cross-communicate in an
antagonistic or synergistic manner, depending on the situation at hand.
Systemic acquired resistance (SAR) is activated in the plant tissues where
localized infection occurs. Upon detecting a pathogen trigger, a mobile signal
fueled by an oxidative burst travels through the vascular system to activate
defense responses in other plant cells. Salicylic acid is the essential signal
molecule at the onset of SAR, as it will be activating a large set of genes that
encode pathogenesis-related proteins with antimicrobial properties. Defensive
phytoalexins accumulate as well … being the phenol, terpenoid, and alkaloid
compounds that attract the attention of herbal orchardists like moi.
Induced systemic resistance (ISR) can be activated upon colonization of plant
roots by beneficial microorganisms, but just as often, its insect chewing or actual
fungal or bacterial disease infection triggering this phytochemical cascade. Like
SAR, a long-distance signal travels through the vascular system to activate
systemic immunity in above-ground plant parts. Jasmonic acid and ethylene are
the primary signals behind the ISR call to action. More than 350 known
secondary plant metabolites are phytoalexins that accumulate as a result.
Making Things Happen
Orchardists can introduce specific triggers to engage ISR defenses. Fatty acids,
polypeptides, inorganic salts, and even some fungicides will do this. Activating
multiple mechanisms with an assortment of foliar inducers is key. Inducing
elicitors include the terpenes found in pure neem oil, the flavonoids in karanja oil,
a host of indigenous herbal remedies, compost teas, effective microbes, ionic
minerals (like Sea-Crop), kelp extracts, and humic acid. Sounds much like our
core holistic spray mix, eh? Only then some!
Effectiveness of holistic applications in the field stretches as long as 10 days to
as much as 14 days in greenhouse trials. Being able to count on a known
residual factor from a ‘green immune boost’ helps in determining appropriate
spray intervals at different pressure points in the orchard year.
Keep in mind that balanced mineral nutrition is necessary for plants to synthesize
this full range of compounds. All the underpinnings of a living soil system must be
in place.
It should be noted that pathogens in particular can adjust to plant defensive
mechanisms by tolerating accumulated phytoalexins, suppressing production of
same, detoxifying by means of counter enzymes, and by avoiding an eliciting
response all together. Nature will continue to evolve in both directions.
Community Orchardist: JAN 2015
Prolonged lack of sunshine radically alters phytochemical oomph as well.
Disease can run amuck when plant defenses are radically toned down, as in the
six weeks of continuous rain and cloud cover experienced in New England in
early summer of 2013. Resorting to organic mineral fungicides in such scenarios
can be considered.
Herbal Tea
Fermented teas of
nettle (two distinct
stages), horsetail, and
comfrey are
recommended in The
Holistic Orchard as
sources of homegrown
calcium and silica. This
last season it finally
dawned on me to make
powerhouse brews from
these basic green teas.
Both the newly-named
Calcium Tea and Silica
Tea come teeming with
biological and nutritional wallop that radically improve leaf vigor and overall tree
health. Yeah, mon. Last year’s apple crop here saw limited scab, sooty blotch
and flyspeck, bitter pit, brooks spot, and other assorted spots come harvest time.
Many more trials need to be done as weather is ever so relevant on the disease
front – and the “recipes” can and should be tweaked to feature local resources–
but what follows is something I hope all holistic growers are inspired to give a try.
Calcium Tea ingredients: comfrey leaf, green nettle, effective microbes,
garlic scapes, raw milk (5 gallons), gypsum, humic and fulvic acids
Silica Tea ingredients: horsetail, seeded nettle, effective microbes,
Azomite clay and/or soft rock phosphate, granite meal and/or basalt dust,
humic and fulvic acids
The basics of these brews work as follows: Cut away the top of a 55-gallon
plastic drum. Gather approximately 20# of green herbs and loose pack into drum.
Fill drum two-thirds of the way with unchlorinated water. Add 2 gallons activated
effective microbes, along with raw milk in the case of the calcium tea. Add 5 to
10# of available rock powders, stirring into solution at the top of the brew. Top off
drum with water, using cut-off tops anchored by bricks to keep herbs in
suspension. Stirring is probably good to enhance breakdown of rock powders but
I did little of this. Fermentation lasts approximately 10 to 14 days, which when
Community Orchardist: JAN 2015
complete is marked by a rather through breakdown of the herbs and an
engrossing smell, to say the least. Roughly remove plant debris using a garden
fork. Add two quarts of humic/fulvic acids per drum. Brew is ready for use but can
also stay in drum for subsequent sprays. A loose cover lessens evaporation.
Up to eight gallons of each tea gets applied per acre. Absolutely run these teas
through strainers (two stages even) before adding to the spray tank. This is
perhaps a generous rate, in my case per 100 gallon spray tank, but the goodness
seems spot on. A minimum dilution would be on the order of 3%, no less. Last
season I applied both teas in the fruit sizing window, from 1st cover through 4th
cover at 7 to 10 day intervals. I continued with the calcium tea in the fruit ripening
window, now at 10 to 14 day intervals up till harvest. These were tank mixed with
seaweed, neem oil, and other ingredients in my ever evolving spray plan.
Some of you may want to add 10# of compost or worm castings ala Jerry
Brunetti to each batch. Epsom salts will benefit trees needing supplemental
magnesium. Molasses feeds bacteria during the breakdown phase. The rules
here are not hard and fast, other than adding the humic and fulvic acids after
fermentation to help chelate released minerals.
Lastly, a sludge note. A goodly charge of the rock powders probably won’t
dissolve into solution. This keys to the fineness of the grind. Don’t worry … any
remaining mineral-rich sludge can be added to a compost pile … which
eventually finds this investment in amendments returned to the soil.
A Plug for Holistic Aesthetics
A series of green men on my barn wall “speak to customers” throughout the fall
harvest time. This particular guy challenged the notion that an occasional spot or
two indicates a bad apple. Geez, boys. You haven’t heard? Fruit that responds to
environmental reality,
being various fungal
diseases, develop
secondary plant
metabolites that are
good for our bodies to
fend off human woes.
It’s a complicated
message needing to
get out as a quick
sound bite … but
coupled with great
tasting samples …
drives the point home
that how we grow food
matters. Amen.
Community Orchardist: JAN 2015
Cidermaker in the News
Andy Brennan of Aaron Burr Cidery in
the lower Hudson Valley of New York
advocates for pressing naturally grown
apples to make cider. The same
principles apply: add a little scab, a pinch
of blotch, this is the basis of
constitutionally rich fruit. Put another
way, overdosing apple trees with
fungicides will not gain one an edge on
the flavor front.
Read more about how Andy is inspiring
people to rethink our connection to the
earth through the apple at
And stay tuned. Andy tells me he hopes
to put together a natural cider summit in
the near future. If that happens, you will
see this event listed on the online
community pages of our website.
Question of the Month
You use effective microorganisms both as a holistic spray and also as a ground spray. I
am wondering how often and under what circumstances you would use microbes as a
ground spray. Is this something you would do regularly? Or only if the soil had been
damaged and you wanted to increase soil microbial populations? In a similar vein, do
you use aerated compost tea also as both a holistic spray and also as a ground spray?
My first application of spring in the orchard is as much directed at the ground as the
tree structure. Same is true for the fall holistic spray. Reinforcing microbe diversity is
just as relevant for thriving ground as damaged soils. That spring app should be
looked at more as a “pulsing agent” to get activity going after the cold of winter.
Similarly, the fall app is engaging feeder root uptake at a critical time as well as
getting leaf decomposition underway to reduce scab inoculum levels. I use the
holistic core recipe in the garden as well. Such sprays definitely complement the soil
food web as well as the arboreal crowd.
Compost tea can certainly be used instead of effective microbes. You simply need
to understand the basics of aeration to achieve a desirable microbe mix. Either/or
works as long as you’re including the deep nutrition component (in the form of fatty
acids) in these biological sprays. I’m not currently set up to brew proper compost
tea – it’s a goal. So working with effective microbes is simpler for me right now. I’d
actually apply the two together as both sets of microbes have great value. The real
skinny here will be revealed by collective experimentation by growers over time.
Community Orchardist: JAN 2015
Apparently one needs to do everything right to grow marketable fruit
organically. Getting 9 out of 10 things right is almost as bad as getting
only 1 out of 10 things right. One has to get 10 out of 10 - or maybe
it's even 20 out of 20! - depending on where you are.
Chris and Michelle McColl, Kalangadoo Orchard
Network Support
Hearty thanks to the growers and business
sponsors listed here. These are the folks
who stepped to the plate with financial
support for this network throughout 2014.
Donations were slightly down this past year
(as can be seen in our annual financial
statement) but then my efforts to pump out
newsletters ran behind as well.
Accomplishments worth noting were
important curriculum articles got posted
and biological discoveries in the growing
season are now being shared.
Our funding mechanisms are much like
public radio: You decide a pledge amount
that works for you. Click that link and then
do your part to help us move ahead.
Sharing more holistic research is a
significant goal for 2015. And then there’s
that “next book” now just taking root.
We do all this together, dear friends.
Stay in touch, think deeply,
and treasure those
venerable trees!
Michael Phillips
Community Orchardist: JAN 2015
Daniel Rinke
Martha Wright – RENEWAL
Cassie Tharinger – NEW MEMBER
Judith Maloney – RENEWAL
Brian Grubb – NEW MEMBER
Paul Loftness – RENEWAL
Hal Palmer – NEW MEMBER
Lucien Hinkle – RENEWAL
Jon Place – RENEWAL
Bruce Carlson
Linda Hoffman – RENEWAL
Anthony Kline – RENEWAL
Organic Gem – RENEWAL
Ahimsa Organics – RENEWAL
Lee Sonneville – NEW MEMBER
Joseph Janicke
Baldwin Ladders – RENEWAL
Susan Fancy
Don Engstrom – RENEWAL
Phil Nauta – NEW MEMBER
David Doncaster – RENEWAL
Debbie Larrimore – NEW MEMBER
Charles Jahn – NEW MEMBER
Joseph Martinez – NEW MEMBER
Chuck Shelton RENEWAL
Diane Depken
William Haines
Curtis Swartzentruber
Paul Gerrish - NEW MEMBER
Steve Dagger - NEW MEMBER
Paul Weir - RENEWAL
Marsha Lindner - RENEWAL
Let’s make 2015 the year
help support the
Holistic Orchard Network!
Community Orchardist: JAN 2015