Consultation outcome report: Upham Meadow (2005110053)

Countryside and Rights of Way (CROW) Act 2000
Prepared by Natural England
Access Authority:
Relevant Authority:
Local Access Forum:
Natural England
Gloucestershire Local Access Forum
Direction reference:
Land Parcel Name
Direction Reference
Details of restriction on
original direction
Upham Meadow
01/03/2010 - 31/07/2010
Every year until
Natural England has now decided how to proceed following its review of the above
mentioned long-term direction to restrict CROW Access rights on this land. A
second consultation has been held between 5th December 2014 and 9th January
2015 with statutory consultees and the general public. We received feedback from
the Ramblers.
In summary their feedback was that as conditions on the site have not changed
since the 2009 reassessment and breeding populations of redshank and curlew still
occur in nationally significant numbers on the site they have no objections to
continuation of the current direction. They do ask that suitable warning notices
explaining the direction are in use at intersections with public rights of way when they
enter and exit the land.
Outcome of the review:
Natural England’s decision is to vary the direction to extend it for a further six years.
Therefore the land will have access excluded between 1st March and 31st July every
year until 2020, to protect breeding populations of Curlew and Redshank.
This direction has been given as Curlew and Redshank are present in nationally
significant breeding populations. Both species are on the Category A species list for
England and are bird species which have been identified by Natural England and the
RSPB as being exceptionally scarce or sensitive to disturbance.
It is thought that changes in agricultural practices such as the switch from hay
making to silage production have left Gloucestershire’s breeding curlew population,
as well as many other farmland birds, sparse in number and in fragmented
populations across the county. These small and increasingly isolated populations are
that much more affected by adverse change, and thus are highly vulnerable to
further pressure from recreational use.
Breeding curlews are especially sensitive to disturbance, being disturbed by an
intruder entering their territory up to 1km away.
The traditional hay making practices at Upham Meadow, being a Lammas Meadow
where a late hay cut is taken, favours these breeding birds, and this combined with
there having not being access historically has allowed these populations to continue
to use the meadows.
Given the sensitivity of these breeding birds and that continued disturbance could
result in the loss of chicks and nests and even Upham Meadow as a breeding site, a
total exclusion is required. A dog exclusion or the national dogs on leads restriction
during this period is not thought to offer enough protection given the sensitivity and
importance of these species.
Natural England’s policy for long term directions is that they should not be given for a
period of more than 6 years. Therefore the original direction will be varied to have an
end date of 31st July 2020.
Access Management
The Second Consultation Report noted that some improvements to the access
furniture at the site are required.
These comprise a new kissing gate at the Sandacre Farm access point and 4 new
robust restriction signs. The two kissing gates will also be kept locked during the
closed period.
Summary of changes made to the existing directions:
Land Parcel Name:
Details of restriction
on original direction:
New details of restriction
Upham Meadow
01/03/2010 - 31/07/2010
Every year until
01/03/2015 - 31/07/2015
Every year until
Details of the restriction will appear on the relevant map of access land on the Open
Access website -
Where a direction restricts access indefinitely, for more than five years, for part of
every year, or for part of at least six consecutive years, we have a statutory duty to
review it within five years of the date of its issue.
Date review completed: 29th January 2015.